Which used van to choose?
The minivan market isn't what it used to be, but for many people, it's still the ultimate family vehicle. Indeed, no SUV offers as much space or as easy access on board. Over time, some have become very sophisticated and offer downright luxurious versions, so their prices can be discouraging. The solution is to turn to a used minivan, but which one?
It's easy to get the impression that manufacturers have colluded, since virtually all available models are powered by a V6 with around 280 hp, can tow up to 3,500 lb, and have a maximum cargo volume of over 4,000 liters. The choice is largely based on other criteria, such as value for money, convenience and reliability.
First, let's settle a question: if you don't want to burn 12-13 L/100 km and stop too often at the gas station, there are two options. The Chrysler Pacifica hybrid (plug-in), which has been around since 2017 and has the advantage of offering an electric range of around 50 km in ideal conditions, has however experienced various reliability and battery problems, making it a risky purchase. Since its 2021 redesign, the Toyota Sienna has been exclusively hybrid (less than 7 L/100 km), even with optional all-wheel drive, but it takes away some power and is noisy under full acceleration.
Both in this generation and the previous one, the Sienna is the van that can carry the largest load. The third row retracts into the floor, but not the second. If you want a flat floor from the tailgate to the front seats, you'll have to look to the Dodge/Chrysler Grand Caravan with its famous Stow 'n Go system. Storage solutions are also plentiful. Alas, mechanical problems and other glitches occur more frequently than with the competition.
Driving enthusiasts who don't really want to feel like they're behind the wheel of a minivan should opt for the Honda Odyssey, arguably the closest thing to a car in terms of roadholding. On the other hand, its mild V6 cannot be combined with all-wheel drive, and tends to be thirsty for fuel. Nor is reliability as good as you'd expect from a Honda product.
By the way, J.D. Power and Consumer Reports magazine generally rank the Sienna at the top of the most reliable minivans. Surprisingly, Kia also finds a way to distinguish itself in this area, whether with the now-defunct Sedona or its replacement, the Carnival. The Korean brand has regularly stood out for its equipment/price ratio, and as its depreciation is higher than that of its Japanese rivals, it's possible to find used examples for less.
In closing, you should know that the Car Guide crowned the Pacifica “Best Buy” in the category from 2017 to 2020 inclusive. Since 2021, however, it's been the Sienna that has kept winning this title. If your budget allows, Toyota's minivan is the best choice on the used market.
